FIELD NOTES HAS MOVED
Notes from the Field is now at http://katrinagulliver.posterous.com
or visit my main site, http://www.katrinagulliver.com
Notes from the Field is now at http://katrinagulliver.posterous.com
or visit my main site, http://www.katrinagulliver.com
I saw a recent episode of Criminal Minds, in which the character Spencer Reid (who has 2 PhDs – neither of them in medicine) explained to the mother of a victim, “I’m a doctor. I think in terms of rationality”. I would NEVER say “I’m a doctor” in that context, and I can’t imagine any of my colleagues doing so. It would seem both pretentious and misleading. It smacks too of hucksters selling self-help books. But in the media, look at the models we have for PhD holders: nerds suffering social arrested development (like those guys on Big Bang Theory – aren’t they professors at CalTech? Why are they still sharing an apartment?), Ross Geller (whose job was also used as a demonstration of geekiness – maybe because his dinosaurs didn’t come alive at night), and Spencer Reid – referred to always as “DR Reid”, which also makes it seem like he’s the only person in the FBI who went to graduate school. Really? Surely half the people there have PhDs in psychology, criminology, or forensics. And the mathematical savant on Numb3rs? It seems like having a PhD may enable someone to catch serial killers, but partly because he is not far from being that “Quiet, white man, of above average intelligence, who probably lives alone....” himself. And when an academic shows up on Law & Order, you just KNOW he was sleeping with an undergrad and strangled his wife. So the model we have is male and (at best) socially dysfunctional. Where are the women, and the PhDs who are not losers?
Last week, I was at the FEEGI conference at Duke. The Forum For European Expansion and Global Interaction (www.feegi.org) has had me as a member for a while, but this was the first time I had attended the biennial conference. And it was GREAT!!
@KristyDermody – Museum curator based in Adelaide
Stepping late here into the churning waters of the job market debate in history. Marc Bosquet has effectively critiqued the AHA’s data (and their “supply side” economic focus). One of the comments on Historiann’s blog added a pertinent point which is often overlooked in this long-running debate. Kathleen Lowrey said
I am on the Coast Starlight, Amtrak’s service from Seattle to Los Angeles. This train features the Pacific Parlour Car (yes, that is PARLOUR with a U), a lounge car for sleeper passengers featuring a bar, some dining tables, and some cool swivel armchairs for looking out the windows. These carriages are originals from the 1950s, restored and brought back into service for just the Coast Starlight. There is also an afternoon wine and cheese tasting (which I hadn’t known about before boarding, so was pleasantly surprised. My previous Amtrak experience was short commuter journeys on the East Coast). This journey really puts European rail travel into true, crummy perspective. Even the so-called “First Class” on the Eurostar is nothing like this good (and the basic class Eurostar “dining car” - which involves being sold some microwave noodles – wouldn’t be so annoying if the tickets weren’t actually more than I paid for this trip, which includes a bed and all meals).
About a week ago, I received an email (from a group I had never heard of) inviting me to move my AHA panel from the Hyatt. The issues were the hotel owner’s stance on gay marriage, and some labour issues. They weren’t offering alternative venues, but suggested that some people were using their own hotel rooms (I am not expecting a huge audience for my paper, but I was hoping for a better crowd than 3 people sitting on my bed). Shortly thereafter, I received a message from the AHA saying much of the message was disinformation, there is no labour dispute at the hotel, and repeating the outcome of discussions at the last AHA meeting: the hotel was booked years ago and pulling out at this stage would be more financially damaging to the AHA than to the hotel. A series of panels on the history of marriage will be held at the Hyatt.